Compare
Foilio vs ManaBox: the free ManaBox alternative
ManaBox is the go-to Magic app for a lot of players: a fast mobile scanner, full deckbuilding, and a collection tracker on iOS and Android. Foilio comes at it from the web: a 100% free, no-install tool that already spans Pokémon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh, is EUR/Cardmarket-native, and is built around decisions (rip-or-hold EV, grade-or-sell, fair-trade) rather than just logging and deckbuilding.
Where ManaBox wins
No tool is best at everything, here's where ManaBox is the stronger pick.
- The most popular Magic-specific app, with an excellent mobile scanner and a deep Magic database.
- Full deckbuilding and playtesting that a web price tool does not try to replace.
- Works offline on your phone, and its CSV format is a community de-facto standard.
- A large, established Magic community.
Web-native versus mobile-first: the core difference
The clearest split between the two is where they live. ManaBox is a mobile app you install from the App Store or Google Play, with an account for cloud sync, and it is built to be your Magic collection in your pocket. Foilio is a web app that opens in any browser with nothing to install and no account to start, so you can value a card or a whole want list from a laptop, a work machine or a borrowed phone in seconds.
Neither approach is strictly better, they suit different habits. If you scan and deckbuild on your phone at your local game store, a native app is the natural home for that. If you want to check a price, run the math on a sealed box, or value a trade from wherever you happen to be, a browser tool that needs no setup wins on friction.
Magic depth versus multi-game breadth
ManaBox is a Magic specialist, and one of the best there is: a large Magic database, a strong scanner, a deck simulator and a trade tool built around the way Magic players actually play. If Magic is the only game you collect, that focus is a genuine advantage.
Foilio trades some of that Magic-specific depth for breadth. It covers Pokémon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh and more in one place, so a collector who keeps a Magic binder next to a Pokémon binder can value both in the same tool. The right pick depends on whether you live in one game or several.
Tracking a collection versus deciding what to do with it
The last difference is what each tool is built to answer. ManaBox answers what you own, what it is worth, and what you can build with it, through tracking, pricing and deckbuilding. Foilio adds a layer on top of the value: it answers what you should do about it. Is this sealed box worth opening rather than buying the singles, is this card worth grading after fees, is this trade actually fair.
In practice a lot of Magic collectors use both: ManaBox as the phone-side scanner and deckbuilder, and Foilio as the free, browser-side second opinion on value and the rip-or-hold, grade-or-sell and fair-trade decisions.
If you live in Magic on your phone and want the best mobile scanner and deckbuilding, ManaBox is superb. If you want a free, no-install tool that works in any browser, covers more than Magic, and gives you rip/grade/trade verdicts with EUR prices, Foilio is the web-native companion.
Just want a ManaBox alternative? See why collectors switch, and when to stay →
Related Foilio tools
Try Foilio free, no account
Look up any card, check if a box is worth ripping, or value your whole want list, in EUR, in your browser, right now.
More comparisons
Questions, answered
Is Foilio a free ManaBox alternative?+
Yes, Foilio is 100% free with no account or app install and runs in any browser. It covers Pokémon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh (not just Magic) and adds decision tools (booster-box EV, grading ROI, trade fairness, deal score) on top of collection tracking. ManaBox is a Magic-first mobile app, so the two complement each other.
Does Foilio work in a browser instead of an app?+
Yes. Foilio runs in any browser with nothing to install; you can optionally add it to your home screen as a PWA. There is no app-store download and no account required to start.
Does Foilio cover more than Magic?+
Yes, Foilio is multi-TCG (Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh and more) with EUR reference prices for each, whereas ManaBox is Magic-first.
Is ManaBox free?+
Yes, ManaBox is free on iOS and Android, with an optional paid tier for cloud sync. Foilio is free too, and runs in any browser with no account needed to start, so both are no-cost ways in; they simply live in different places, a mobile app versus a web tool.
Does Foilio have a scanner like ManaBox?+
Yes. Foilio scans cards in the browser, on your device, and adds them to your collection free with no scan limit. ManaBox's scanner is a strong native mobile one built around Magic; Foilio's works across games in any browser.
Is there a web version of ManaBox?+
ManaBox is a mobile app on iOS and Android. If you specifically want a Magic collection and price tool that runs in a browser with nothing to install, that is what Foilio is, and it adds booster-box EV, grading ROI and trade-fairness verdicts on top.
Comparison compiled 2026 from public sources (ManaBox: ManaBox); features and pricing change, verify current details with each provider. Foilio is an independent project, not affiliated with ManaBox.